Are Merchant Cash Advances Legal? 2026 Rules, State Laws and Red Flags

Yes, merchant cash advances are legal. No state has banned the product, and courts, regulators and legislatures all treat a purchase of future receivables as a lawful commercial transaction. But "legal to offer" is not the same as "legal however it is written." A court decides what a contract really is by looking at how it works, not at what the first page calls it, and a growing list of states now require providers to show you standardized costs before you sign. This guide explains the test courts use, the state laws in force, what regulators have done, and a checklist for protecting your business.

A merchant cash advance (MCA) is structured as a sale: a funder buys a portion of your future receivables at a discount and collects it from a share of your daily or weekly revenue, priced with a factor rate instead of an interest rate. That structure is the reason MCAs are generally not treated as loans. It is also the reason lawyers argue about it, because the label only holds up if the contract behaves like a sale.

This is general information, not legal advice. Laws and court decisions change, they differ by state, and they apply differently to different contracts. If you are signing, disputing or being sued over a specific agreement, talk to a licensed attorney in your state.

⚡ KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • MCAs are a legal, widely used form of business funding, but a court can treat one as a loan if it works like one
  • The usual test asks three things: is there a reconciliation right, is there a finite term, and is there recourse if your business fails
  • Disclosure laws in California, New York and other states require standardized cost figures at offer, and some states also limit confessions of judgment
  • The fastest protection is to read the reconciliation clause, the default terms and the total repayment before you sign
  • This page is educational and is not legal advice

Is an MCA legal? What "legal" actually means

When people search "is MCA legal" or "is a merchant cash advance legal," they are usually asking one of three different questions, and the answers differ.

Can a company offer an MCA at all? Yes. A purchase of future receivables is an ordinary commercial contract. This page covers the law as it applies to MCA contracts and the disclosures around them.

Is an MCA a loan? Generally no, if it is structured and operated as a true sale of receivables. This matters because loans are subject to interest-rate caps (usury laws) and an MCA that is not a loan is not. But this is a question of substance, covered in the next section.

Is the way a particular funder behaves legal? That depends on the contract and the conduct. Fraud, deceptive practices and unauthorized withdrawals are illegal regardless of how the product is labeled. Regulators have brought cases over exactly this, and they are summarized below.

How courts decide if an MCA is a true sale or a disguised loan

The question that drives most MCA litigation is whether the advance is repayable "absolutely" or only out of your future revenue. If your repayment is absolute, a court may call the deal a loan and apply usury law. If repayment is truly contingent on your receivables, it is more likely a sale.

New York courts, which hear a large share of MCA disputes because many contracts choose New York law, have used a three-factor test. In Principis Capital, LLC v. I Do, Inc., the Appellate Division, Second Department, decided January 12, 2022, said courts weigh three factors when deciding whether repayment is absolute or contingent:

  1. Is there a reconciliation provision? Does the agreement let your payments adjust, up or down, to match your actual receipts?
  2. Is there a finite term? Is there a fixed date by which the funder must be repaid, or does the length depend on how fast your sales come in?
  3. Is there recourse if the merchant goes bankrupt? Does a bankruptcy filing count as a default that lets the funder collect anyway?

In Principis, the court found that the payment amount could change with the merchant's monthly sales, so the term was not finite, and that nothing made a bankruptcy filing an event of default. It held that the agreement was not a "loan" to which the usury defense applied, and reversed the lower court. The court also repeated the general rule that unless a principal sum advanced is repayable absolutely, the transaction is not a loan.

Two cautions apply. First, this is one New York appellate court applying New York law to one contract. Other courts, other states and other contracts can come out differently, and a contract that fails the factors can be treated as a loan. Second, the test looks at what the contract says and how the funder actually behaves. A reconciliation clause that exists on paper but is never honored in practice is exactly what regulators have attacked, as the enforcement section below shows.

What each factor looks like in a contract

FactorPoints toward a true salePoints toward a disguised loan
ReconciliationWritten right to adjust payments to actual receipts, with a clear process and timelineNo adjustment right, or one so hard to use that it is never granted
TermNo fixed end date; repayment time depends on your revenueA fixed date or fixed number of payments that must be met no matter what sales do
Bankruptcy and business failureFunder bears the loss if your receivables stopBankruptcy or closure is a default that triggers full repayment, or a personal guarantee covers business failure

A personal guarantee is not automatically a problem. Some MCA contracts limit the guarantee to specific bad acts, such as fraud or diverting receipts. A guarantee of the full repayment if the business simply fails to generate revenue moves the deal toward a loan.

Usury and recharacterization: can an MCA be illegal for charging too much?

Usury laws cap interest on loans. An MCA is not priced with interest, so if it is a true sale, usury caps do not apply. That is why MCA cost is expressed as a factor rate and a total payback amount, and why factor rate vs. APR is such a common point of confusion.

The risk is recharacterization. If a court decides the contract is a loan, usury law can apply, and a transaction that was priced far above a state's legal rate could be unenforceable or carry penalties. This is the legal basis for the phrases people search, such as "is a merchant cash advance illegal" and "merchant cash advance usury." In practice, many MCAs survive that challenge because they pass the three-factor test above, and courts have enforced them. Some have not.

The New York Attorney General's Yellowstone settlement, covered below, shows the other side of this. The AG alleged that contracts which described each deal as a purchase of future revenue actually functioned as short-term loans with annualized rates of up to 820 percent, more than 50 times New York's legal interest rate. That is an allegation settled by a judgment, but it shows why recharacterization is not theoretical.

Confessions of judgment: what the law limits

A confession of judgment (COJ) is a clause in which you agree in advance that a court can enter judgment against you if you default, without your having a chance to respond. Funders have used them to collect quickly, and they are among the most contested terms in MCA contracts.

States have started to restrict them. Two examples read directly from the statute text on the states' own sites:

Other states have their own rules, and they vary on who is covered, which deals are covered and what happens to a clause that is already in a contract. Check your state's current law, and read the default section of any contract for words like "confession," "consent judgment" or "waiver of notice" before you sign.

State commercial-financing disclosure laws

A disclosure law does not ban MCAs and does not turn them into loans. It requires the provider to give you standardized numbers at the time of an offer so you can compare offers. Providers must give these disclosures when the law applies to the transaction.

Here is what could be verified on each state's own statute, regulation or regulator page as of November 18, 2026. It is a summary of selected states, not a complete list, and not every state with a rule is shown.

StateLawKey datesWhat it covers
CaliforniaSB 1235 and DFPI commercial financing disclosure regulationsSB 1235 enacted September 30, 2018; regulations approved June 9, 2022; disclosures effective December 9, 2022Providers of commercial financing, including merchant cash advances, must disclose items such as the amount of funding, an estimated APR, the term, payment details and prepayment policy
New YorkCommercial Finance Disclosure Law (Financial Services Law Article 8) and 23 NYCRR Part 600DFS adopted Part 600 on February 1, 2023; it takes effect on publication of the notice of adoption, with a compliance date six months after that publicationStandardized disclosures at the time of offer for commercial financing at or below a $2.5 million threshold, with specific formats for sales-based financing, including an estimated APR
VirginiaCode of Virginia Title 6.2, Chapter 22.1 (sales-based financing providers)Providers and brokers had to register on or before November 1, 2022Disclosure of financing amount, finance charge, total repayment and estimated payments at the time of a specific offer; confessions of judgment barred
FloridaFlorida Commercial Financing Disclosure Law, Chapter 2023-290Law took effect July 1, 2023; it applies to transactions consummated on or after January 1, 2024Disclosures for covered commercial financing transactions of $500,000 or less; certain providers and transactions are exempt
ConnecticutPublic Act 23-201, Conn. Gen. Stat. 36a-861 to 36a-872Effective July 1, 2024; registration due by October 1, 2024Sales-based financing of up to $250,000; disclosure form at offer, plus the prejudgment-remedy waiver limit above

A few notes on reading this table.

Which states treat merchant cash advances as loans?

People often search for "states that treat merchant cash advances as loans," and a clean list does not exist. No state has passed a statute that says every merchant cash advance is a loan. Instead:

Regulator enforcement: what the FTC and New York have done

Enforcement is where the question "is this legal" gets concrete. Two actions, both documented in the agencies' own press releases, show what regulators have targeted.

Federal Trade Commission, April 22, 2021. The FTC announced that Yellowstone Capital, Fundry Inc., and two individuals agreed to surrender $9,837,000 to settle charges that the merchant cash advance provider misled small businesses and made unauthorized withdrawals. According to the FTC, the company kept pulling money from business bank accounts after those businesses had already repaid what they owed, often misrepresented how much funding businesses would actually receive, and misstated requirements such as collateral and personal guarantees. The money went toward refunds to affected businesses.

New York Attorney General, January 22, 2025. The Attorney General announced a settlement with a network of 25 companies controlled by Yellowstone and its officers. The settlement includes a $1.065 billion judgment, with more than $534 million satisfied by canceling all outstanding debts owed by small businesses, and $16.1 million paid immediately toward distribution to affected businesses. The AG alleged that contracts described each transaction as a purchase of future revenue with flexible payment amounts and open-ended terms, while the companies collected fixed daily amounts over short periods, and that the promised reconciliation was designed so borrowers almost never qualified for refunds.

The lesson is not that MCAs are illegal. It is that the paper structure does not protect a funder whose conduct contradicts it, and that regulators look at the conduct. For you, that means the reconciliation clause matters only if it works in practice.

How to protect yourself: an MCA contract checklist

You do not need a law degree to catch the biggest problems. Before you sign any MCA, work through this list, and ask a lawyer to review anything you are unsure about. Our questions to ask before you sign an MCA goes deeper.

Red flags that deserve a hard look

How Byzfunder handles it

Byzfunder is a direct lender that has provided more than $2 billion in financing to over 35,000 businesses since 2019, funding from its own balance sheet. Its merchant cash advance is a purchase of future receivables priced with a factor rate, not a loan, and its ByzFlex product is revenue-based revolving capital. The credit floor is 525 FICO for the MCA and 550 for ByzFlex, and meeting a minimum does not guarantee approval.

Because state disclosure rules and court tests change, the practical approach for any business is the same: get the written offer, compare the total repayment, and read the contract before you sign. Whichever funder you choose, do the same, and have an attorney review any agreement you are unsure about. For how MCAs work step by step, see how a merchant cash advance works, and for a comparison of providers, see merchant cash advance companies, and for other options, merchant cash advance alternatives. If your credit is a concern, read merchant cash advance with bad credit.

Frequently asked questions

Is an MCA legal?

Yes. Merchant cash advances are a legal form of business funding in the United States, and they are generally not loans. An MCA is structured as a purchase of future receivables. If a court decides a particular contract works like a loan, it can be treated as one and usury law may apply.

Is a merchant cash advance legal?

Yes. A purchase of future receivables is a lawful commercial transaction, and no state has banned the product. Providers must follow general contract and deceptive-practices law, and, where they apply, state commercial-financing disclosure laws.

Is MCA legal in New York and California?

Yes, in both. California and New York require providers to give standardized disclosures at offer, including an estimated APR, for covered commercial financing. California's disclosures took effect December 9, 2022, and New York's regulation is 23 NYCRR Part 600, adopted by DFS on February 1, 2023.

Is a merchant cash advance illegal?

Not as a category. The usual legal fight is whether a specific contract is really a loan, which courts decide using factors such as a reconciliation right, a finite term and recourse on bankruptcy. A contract that fails the test can be recharacterized, and funders that mislead borrowers or take unauthorized payments have faced regulators.

Can a merchant cash advance be charged too much interest and break usury law?

Usury caps apply to loans. If an MCA is a true sale, usury does not apply. If a court treats it as a loan, usury law can apply, and a very high effective rate could make the contract unenforceable or subject to penalties, depending on the state.

What states treat merchant cash advances as loans?

There is no verified list of states where every merchant cash advance is a loan. Courts decide case by case, and some state statutes regulate MCAs through disclosure rules without calling them loans. Ask anyone who gives you a list to cite the statute or decision.

Are confessions of judgment legal in MCA contracts?

It depends on the state. Virginia makes a confession of judgment in a sales-based financing contract unenforceable, and Connecticut makes a waiver of notice and a hearing before certain prejudgment remedies unenforceable in contracts entered into on or after July 1, 2024. Other states have their own rules.

Do MCA providers need a license?

That depends on the state and the provider. Some states, including Virginia and Connecticut, require providers and brokers of sales-based financing to register, and disclosure laws apply separately. Check your state's financial regulator for current requirements.

Is a merchant cash advance regulated?

Yes, in several ways. General contract law, deceptive-practices law and state disclosure laws apply, and the FTC and state attorneys general have brought enforcement actions against funders accused of misleading small businesses.

What should I check before I sign an MCA?

The total repayment in writing, the reconciliation clause, whether there is a fixed end date, the default and personal guarantee terms and any confession of judgment. Have an attorney review the agreement if you are unsure.

Is this legal advice?

No. This page is general information. For advice on a specific contract or dispute, talk to a licensed attorney in your state.

What this means for your business

An MCA is a legitimate, legal tool for a business that needs cash fast and can live with the cost, which is higher than a bank or SBA loan. The legal protections are real but uneven: they depend on your state, your contract and how the funder behaves. The best protection is the one you control, which is reading the numbers and the reconciliation and default terms before you sign.

Byzfunder funds businesses directly from its own balance sheet, with credit floors of 525 for the MCA and 550 for ByzFlex. Every offer depends on your file and no approval is guaranteed. See if your business qualifies.

See what your business qualifies for
$2B+ funded · 35,000+ businesses · same-day funding
Apply in minutes →

References

  1. California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, "DFPI's Commercial Financing Disclosure Regulations Approved to Become Effective as of December 9, 2022," June 14, 2022, accessed Nov 18, 2026. dfpi.ca.gov
  2. New York Department of Financial Services, 23 NYCRR Part 600, commercial finance disclosure regulation (text, including section 600.25 on effective and compliance dates), accessed Nov 18, 2026. dfs.ny.gov
  3. New York Department of Financial Services, "Superintendent Adrienne A. Harris Adopts Updated Regulation For Disclosure Requirements For Commercial Financing," February 1, 2023, accessed Nov 18, 2026. dfs.ny.gov
  4. Code of Virginia, Title 6.2, Chapter 22.1, Sales-Based Financing Providers, sections 6.2-2230, 6.2-2231 and 6.2-2234, accessed Nov 18, 2026. law.lis.virginia.gov
  5. Connecticut General Statutes, Chapter 669, sections 36a-861 to 36a-872 (Public Act 23-201), accessed Nov 18, 2026. cga.ct.gov
  6. Florida Laws, Chapter 2023-290 (CS/HB 1353), Florida Commercial Financing Disclosure Law, accessed Nov 18, 2026. laws.flrules.org
  7. Federal Trade Commission, "Cash Advance Firm to Pay $9.8M to Settle FTC Complaint It Overcharged Small Businesses," April 22, 2021, accessed Nov 18, 2026. ftc.gov
  8. New York Attorney General, "Attorney General James Announces $1 Billion Settlement with Predatory Lender Yellowstone Capital for Harming Small Businesses," January 22, 2025, accessed Nov 18, 2026. ag.ny.gov
  9. Principis Capital, LLC v. I Do, Inc., New York Appellate Division, Second Department, decided January 12, 2022 (2022 NY Slip Op 00203), disposition as reproduced by Leagle and holding as summarized by the New York Appellate Digest, accessed Nov 18, 2026. leagle.com and newyorkappellatedigest.com